Posts
Mark, 27-10:
Following on from our dip into ska memories recently!
Gary, 27-10:🖖🏻
Gary, 28-10:
By the way, I have always liked the band Bread… besides the mainstream 70s hits some of their album tracks are worth a listen… David Gates’ solo album First has the track ‘Suite: Clouds and Rain’ which is also one of my favourites… a novel musical construct but also maybe a guilty pleasure?😁
Mark, 28-10:
Aaah…..probably me being harsh again and I admit I hardly know
their records - a few of their big hits just hazily remembered. However,
they epitomize seventies "soft rock" and all-white AOR that is
well-crafted and impeccably played music but lacking guts, grit,
messages or rough edges, and so I lump them in with other famous names
that similarly just do not cut it for me and have no place in my
otherwise, I would say, quite diverse record collection, like Genesis,
Fleetwood Mac, Hall & Oates, Elton John, Queen, Doobie Brothers, Z Z
Top......
Borderline (or should I say on the border!) are The Eagles
because they were country rock pioneers with some oomph courtesy of
Bernie Leadon who is linked to the great Gram Parsons: they were both
members of the Flying Burrito Brothers. So The Eagles just about cut it
for me until the point he left which was when the band became bloated
with stadium-rock success and increasingly bitter personal rivalry. As
punk raged across the music scene I sold my original copy of Hotel
California - but bought it again after visiting the hotel on the album
sleeve during an ICANN trip to LA!
Another possible case for acceptance are the Allman Brothers Band:
the thrilling guitar prowess of Duane Allman provides the pass into my
record collection I guess.
Of the solo singer-songwriters of that era, I've got lp's by
Jackson Browne (whose voice certainly sounds very soft) and James Taylor
(more edgy) who are both arguably vulnerable to negative AOR tagging.
However, at their peak they were top notch writers so OK for me on that
scoring. Carly Simon is also safe on the shelves until she went
mainstream in the 1980s. Paul Simon wobbled a bit in terms of relevance
but who can dare dismiss his achievements in the 1960s (some very
political songs then too)? Great credit also to him for sticking his
neck out with his engaging South African and Brazilian music in the
1980s. Never any risk of Joni Mitchell or Neil Young falling into the
AOR trap.
………... so take it easy!"
Oh Mark, I think you have just asked me that question that you will have wished you had never asked!😂
As you may recall Mark, within in our past frequent
work-time discussions this is a subject that has irked me over so many
years and may explain why I love (for a better term) ‘Prog Rock’ so
much.
I have always listened to ‘music’ for what it is, an
artistic medium that means something to you as an individual, music
should produce beauty of form, harmony, and expression of emotion. But
that could also be in the form of excitement, aggressive or negative
emotions or feelings. I have never been one to listen to music because
it is associated with a social movement or ‘scene’. Indeed, the latter
apparent attitude taken by many people when ‘attempting’ to enjoy music
is illogical and potentially missing out on a greater gift and
experience, because “its not cool to enjoy that scene”! You can exchange
the latter quote to whatever common vernacular you wish to choose or
may have heard😉.
In my view it is a big mistake, although I grant you
convenient, to classify and compartmentalise music as it should always
be experienced or appreciated for what it is, not because the musician
has blue hair, wears his baseball cap on his/her head back-to-front or
has strident fashionable, political or cultural views. To me this has
been what is so terribly wrong with the music scene since the mid-70s,
too much focus on what is ‘cool’, fashionable and more widely prevalent
homage to the media’s Cult of Celebrity! Although there is a valid
connection between music and dance, in my view, dance now is considered
to be the only reason music exists…. This view is oh-so-wrong! Music is
so much more, to me the purest form of music has little or no vocals and
most certainly is not just a song! Of course, I enjoy ‘a good toon’,
meaningful and inspiring lyrics and even a cheerful whistle as I walk
along, but today in our culture that seems to be more the norm and not
(in my view as it should be) the exception!
Rap is also an incredibly limiting medium (or at least to
my ears)… I have no problem with anyone enjoying it, but it seems that
it now excludes other musicians and writers from gaining access to
public exposure and inspiration.
You mention the terms AOR, Stadium-Rock, Punk and I will
infer Country and singer-songwriter, this is where I believe the core of
our cultural problem is, the very action of classifying excludes valid
and exceptional pieces of art. This why I love ‘Prog’ (if you have to
put a title on it) so much because eclectic, taking inspiration and
borrowing from all areas of music and culture to produce music at what I
consider its highest levels of quality and experience. I am not saying
you have to like what is produced, but to dismiss it without
understanding what has gone into producing it or the levels of
potential appreciation and enjoyment from listening to it is unfair and
actually very negative.
You briefly mention ‘Punk’ and what is today considered to
have broken the 70s music industry as being a positive effect. I
disagree completely with this view, it had negative affect on music as
an art form, because what came with Punk and commercialism thereafter
killed the creative process. In my view Punk was nothing more than a
fashion statement, very little true musical value was produced (not to
say there were not some gems amongst the dirt). There seemed to be a
confusion between what is music and what is fashion, to me the two
should not be merged as music usually comes off worse! In my personal
view Punk’s popularity was an early manifestation of what is today's
Populist culture, it could be described as being a reactionary movement
instigated by clever manipulators like Malcolm McClaren that ended with
global success but basically was just another version of the 'Emperor's
New Clothes’… sadly people do not learn from mistakes like this and now
we have degenerated into getting a US president like Trump… all talk but
no thought!
My philosophy has always been enjoy music on its own
merits and not be swayed by someone in the media that tells you its
uncool or rubbish as the chances are they themselves have been told to
think that way!
Rant over!
Wo., 30-10:
Having enjoyed a few days off
hiking the north east of the country and visiting the in-laws in the
south west and then doing my company's taxes there's some time to enter
this new discussion.
The
Specials back in action?! I bet the tickets will be quite steep and the
new music a lame version of what they were able to do? Or maybe not and
it will be a good album? We'll have to wait and see. All in the
original line up, so with Jerry Dammers?
It's
years ago that I've gone through the endless baskets with old records
filled with the kind of hopeless releases that I tried to avoid as much
as possible 40 years ago, in the hope of finding that one album. For one
I'm too lazy, for two my knees are far from what they used to be when I
was 16 or something. These baskets are usually on floor level, so I
leave them for what they are. Nice alliteration by the way, Mark, all
those B's.
What
would I never buy? Certainly classics, jazz, pre-1964 pop albums, not
to speak of all the albums I never should have bought like the
non-greatest hits albums of Golden Earring, new wave stuff with one to
three good tracks on them, 70s AOR like Rod Stewart, 70s, early 80s West
Coast artists like James Taylor, Crosby-Nash, Carly Simon. I just can't
listen to these too difficult songs with a jazz tinge in them. Sorry,
Gary, most prog-rock is just not my thing. Too difficult and elaborate
for my ears. Those solo albums by band members of famous bands. Soul, disco, dance, rap, trance, trip hop, C&W, (nu) metal, AOR and hardrock. Yet, they all have their exceptions. Some great singles or a great album track that make me blur the lines for a short while.
I have to give it to the youngsters I know well. They speak of the latest rappers, rap
together every once in a while and watch videos, I think, on their
smartphones, but enjoy the oldies, from the 60s to the 90s, just as much
and gladly join me at an The Analogues show to listen to The Beatles'
music live. My influence? Yes, of course, but a lot they find themselves
on Spotify.
And for punk. No, I've written it before, it was nearly
not for me in the 70s. That started with Green Day and The Offspring in
the mid 90s for me, when I started to look back and found great music.
Yes, The Sexpistols were a pre-fabbed lot, but the New York scene was
more original in my opinion. The scene that gave us Patti Smith, The
Ramones, Talking Heads, Blondie, Television, etc. was far more original
and honest. On the other hand, every generation needs something to kick
on and at. Perhaps that's what's wrong with today. No youngsters kick
anything any more or their parents were, even are, so bad, there's nothing to beat
or kick against. We have done it all and boasting about it as well.
I played that record by The Beat again today. "Oh, what fun we had...", to quote that other ska heroes of mine.
Mark, 4-11:
There's so much music around these days - as you report at regular
intervals in your blogs, Wout - I see it in the magazines too and hear
just a fraction on the radio in the evening on BBC Radio 6. It's obvious
there is so much new talent around and that so many people in the
countries we know see music as the way to express themselves in an
artistic and skilful way, it's very reassuring. I think it helps to
restore your faith in humanity at a time when it seems we are on a
downward spiral with political divisiveness and aggression everywhere,
and the global environment suffering and fear growing that we are
running out of time and we are not going to turn all this round for the
sake of our children and grandchildren.
When you consider all the history, roots and evolution over the
last few decades of the music we love and the incredible variety today
of different styles of music, I think the availability and access to
music is much more balanced now than what it was back in the 1970s. For
example, if you listen to Radio 6 on a typical evening it draws on much
of this rich heritage switching from rock to ska to African to country
to reggae to progressive to folk to blues to Cuban to electronic to
rock'n'roll to jazz-rock to heavy rock - not much gets left out really -
plus new records and sessions in the studio. If you stop by one of the
bigger newsagents and scan the music section, in addition to the big
monthlies like Uncut, Mojo and Q (which each cover most kinds of music),
you see individual magazines that have sprung up in recent years
specialising in folk roots, progressive, heavy metal, rock'n'roll, punk,
electronic, jazz....quite amazing when you remember 40 years ago in the
UK it was basically the NME, Melody Maker or Sounds - all weekly
newspapers. There is much less snobbery I think that one kind of music
is superior to all others; or that folk is only for a particular kind of
rustic intellectual; or that progressive is for hopeless hippies and
weirdoes...… Instead it seems the panorama of music is much more
connected up and people who love and consume music are much more
tolerant and willing to diversify their musical interests. The changes
in media technology have been a great help - especially with opening up
the archives and keeping in the musical consciousness of many more
people what was originally considered to be ephemeral, worthless and
soon to be forgotten. A lot of John Peel sessions going back to the late
1960s are now being played again on Radio 6; the tapes could so easily
have been wiped because I don't think anybody then would have expected
that 30 years later we would have time to listen again to all those
sessions, never mind have an interests in doing so.
I happily roam around quite a lot of this diversity of music and
find new kinds and artists young and old to check out. It is almost too
much to handle now though and I find myself having to draw the line
somewhere. I realise, Gary , that that can be quite arbitrary as it is
usually done by deciding which artists I'm not interested in or dislike
for some reason regardless of what he/she/they might have done. I named
several in my previous e-mail and was curious only if you and Wout were
also having to draw lines and how our thumbs down might compare.
I've just bought on e-bay a shiny original copy of The Best of The Beach Boys Vol.3:
All the places we've surfed and danced and
All the faces we've missed so let's get
Back together and do it again.
Thank you for this very thoughtful piece, Mark.
Where the thumbs down is concerned, I find with being sent music
regularly by small press agencies and smaller and bigger labels my mind
is so much more open to other forms of music, in the sense of open to
the unknown. My preferences have not so much change a lot, although I
have been surprised several times. It is more that I find beautiful
music made by obscure musicians, even by bands that are nearly 100% DIY
and are only able to perform a few times a year and for small audiences
at that. All this huge dedication to a muse almost no else seems to find
of interest, is so admirable. With me cheering at the side line. Yes,
this way I have discovered a few truly ***** LPs almost nobody else
seems to know or appreciate. For that reason alone I'd wish more people
read my blog and become inspired by it.
Of all that new music I at least try to listen once. Sometimes it stays
there, it is impossible to please every one, sometimes I return after a
while and find to have had my ears screwed on wrong at the first
attempt. One thing has changed, thrice over. First with all the
downloading, which was legal (or said to be by leading politicians) in
this country, I found that music starting to lose all value. There was
no way I was able to attach myself to a MP3, secondly with all this new
music I am listening for the blog all the time and writing about it, I
also lost connection to the music in the longer term. Yet, closing in on
6 years blogging, the attachment to music certainly has returned.
Several bands truly have become favourites and albums very much
cherished. This has to do with the first change, the fact that I started
buying LPs again. This really changed my connection to music for the
positive. Albums are expensive, so I better buy one I really like
playing. Friday I spent € 50 on a double album, 'Komma' by broeder
Dieleman. Look it up, it is a true work of art this album. (Of course)
the music is super special as well.
So, a real stop at this point in time is price. I refuse to pay more
than €25,= for an LP. If I really want the record then I settle for the
cd. For the rest I receive so much music that there is nearly no a need
to buy anything else, except the ones I really, really want to have. And
sit down and play them while really listening. Something I had not
really done for years with all the "free" MP3s flying around the house.
Since several years downloading is formally illegal here as well and
I've stopped doing it. Not even being tempted any more.
Summing up, I have become a fan of Bands like Franz Ferdinand, Arctic
Monkeys, Kaizers Orchestra, Blood Red Shoes and Band of Skulls in the
00s and a host of bands and artists in the 10s, with most recently truly
fantastic albums by Belgian TMGS, Austrian Cari Cari and
U.S./Belgian/Dutch/Slovenian Distance, Light & Sky, all 4,5 to 5
star albums in two weeks' time.
Music, I love it. And in the band one of the guys this week said he wants to play Sade's cover of 'Why Can't We Live Together'. The result I hear Tina Turner's 'Let's Stay Together' and Joe Cocker's version of 'You Can Leave Your Hat On' the whole day in my head. Music? I love it.
Music, I love it. And in the band one of the guys this week said he wants to play Sade's cover of 'Why Can't We Live Together'. The result I hear Tina Turner's 'Let's Stay Together' and Joe Cocker's version of 'You Can Leave Your Hat On' the whole day in my head. Music? I love it.
BTW, The Specials were advertised here last week. A new album is
underway. Tickets go for € 43,=. I wish them all the best but won't be
there to listen.
Gary
Mark
Wo.
P.S. Playing Sade turns out to be a load of fun. The timing is extremely hard, so a great challenge and fun, but I'd already mentioned that.
Gary
Mark
Wo.
P.S. Playing Sade turns out to be a load of fun. The timing is extremely hard, so a great challenge and fun, but I'd already mentioned that.
No comments:
Post a Comment