Let's call 1979 the birth year of postpunk, with the early 80s defining the genre in a far sharper and militant way. If we take that as the starting point, bands like Simple Minds evolved into smooth hit bands within a few years (at the time half a decade!). Fontaines DC evolves along the same lines, except that number 1 hits are well beyond possible for this sort of music today. It escapes me why that is, but that is another discussion.
The music is even beyond what the previous album, 'Romance', offered. The line forward is clear though. More keyboards, more smoothness and an ever bigger role for singer Grian Chatten. Whether that makes it more of a Grian Chatten band/album, is something I can't judge. It is the feeling I have, drawn from the band's last two albums. The same happened to Wolf Alice for example. Fontaines DC still erupts every once in a while though, showing its prickly side with relish.
With Dopamine Chamber the Irish band operating from London explores its musicality further. That leads to the use of less guitars and more keyboards, pianos and synths, giving several songs a new feel. It is not just a mood change, like the opening and title song on 'Romance'. That made it very clear something had changed, while still being recognisably Fontaines DC, mixed with a sense of anxiety and suspense. With 'Six Shot Morning' something identical is done but at the next level. From there an adventure is starting that takes the listeners to different levels, moods and musicality that definitely are not Fontaines DC as we knew the band to be.
The reason why I doubt the album still at this point, is that some songs are so simple in structure. Take the opening sequence of 'One Man'. When all is said and done, nothing is happening there. It's almost like the Coldplay feeling I had when I listened to parts of 'X&Y' for the first time. Although the same chords are repeated over and over, finally something does happen, like at the end of 'Fix You', but still, is this want I want to hear from this band? On the other hand there are a few beautiful and surprising songs on Dopamine Chamber that make me like the album more by now.
The song nearly everyone commenting on the album picks out is 'Where Is Gone?', featuring Rosalia. It makes me think of a song, also a duet, I have long forgotten the name of by an obscure singer from the U.S. that I had never heard of before nor since. For the life of me, I can't recall the title or artist*. Just the feel that is so identical. Then take 'Japan'. Fontaines DC takes a pop ballad to perfection here.
Bands evolve, well the bigger and better ones do. Fontaines DC definitely has evolved and will remain doing so, in the mean time gathering more and more fans along the way. My verdict at this point in time remains in the balance. This album can go the 'X&Y' route still. The other option is that it will keep growing on me and turn into one of my favourites of 2026. Exciting isn't it?
Wout de Natris - van der Borght
* Since writing, I ran into the name of the website Noisetrade and that helped me find the song and artist. It is 'Dancing In A Dream' by Jon DeRosa with Carina Round. The mood of the songs are so similar.
You can listen to and order Dopamine Chamber here:
https://fontainesdc.bandcamp.com/album/dopamine-chamber





.jpg)
















